Fall is the perfect time to refresh your beauty routine. The temps are dropping, our wardrobes are getting cozier, and there’s that “new school year” feeling in the air. And while sometimes a complete Home Edit–style overhaul may be in order, often just one product swap can refresh your entire routine. But with so many options out there, it helps to have some professional guidance. So who better to share their favorite products for the season than the very people who get to test them out first for a living? I tapped beauty editors from Elle, Harper’s Bazaar, Real Simple, and others (including yours truly—I couldn’t help myself) to share the products they’re relying on most this season. From brand-new launches to old favorites they’re rediscovering, you’re guaranteed to find your new go-to on this list. Read on to shop their fall must-haves and learn why they think you’ll love them too.